A Case of Educational Change:
Improving Student Achievement Through a School-University Partnership
November,
2004
The Article
This article by Associate Professor Troy Mariage and colleague
Arthur Garmon (Western Michigan University) describe their five-year
project that sought to develop a collaborative site of practice and
inquiry among two universities, the primary and elementary schools
in a poor rural town, and the district that served these schools.
Discussion
The authors note that there is an urgent need to demonstrate how
school-university partnerships can affect student achievement in the
most underperforming schools. “Unfortunately, there has been scant
evidence that these relationships result in improved learning for
large numbers of students, especially the most at-risk learners…”
Their intervention, known as Project PREPARE, involved a poor rural
community in Michigan. The site for the study was a primary (K-2)
and an elementary (grades 3-5) school, which served 750 students and
employed 39 faculty members. Test scores indicated the district was
the lowest achieving of the 37 districts in southwest Michigan. Two
universities and one Intermediate School District were included in
the development of the collaborative site. The project involved
three types of collaboration: (a) providing consultative and
material support to changes initiated by the district, (b) creating
new collaborative structures that could serve as sites for advancing
teacher and student learning, and (c) providing conceptual
leadership to help the district develop a long-range systemic change
initiative. During the course of the project, there were steady
improvements in student achievement in reading and mathematics on
multiple measures, including state-mandated criterion-referenced
tests and curriculum-based measures. In fact, the combined reading
and math increases were greater in the project school during the
study period than in 9 of the 10 closest comparison schools in
Michigan. The authors conclude that Project PREPARE is not a model
that necessarily can or should be implemented in other
underperforming schools, for “school-university partnerships will
continue to be highly idiosyncratic.” Instead, they suggest that the
project is an example of a case in which a school-university
partnership advanced teacher and student learning “in one of our
most underperforming schools.”
What It Means To You
Mariage and Garmon are careful to point out that each
school-university partnership poses its own set of challenges.
However, as is clear from Project PREPARE, the collaborations can
yield positive results for teachers and student learning. In our
most under performing schools, there is often a need to “reculture”
schools into learning organizations. Partnerships are one strategy
that schools can use in the that process. The school/university
partnership can serve as a catalyst for generating the expertise
needed to provide conceptual clarity to the change process and
sustain these processes over time.
For More Information
Mariage, T. V. & Garmon, M. A. (2003). A case of educational change:
Improving student achievement through a school-university
partnership. Remedial and Special Education, (24)4, 215-234.
< back to 2004 ed-research reports |